Skip to main content

Evaluation of Method in Math

(The following article by Upper School Math Coordinator Nick Reeb appears in the winter 2014 issue of Saint David's Magazine.)

It is no surprise to learn that in order to attain mathematical fluency, we must develop our calculation and reasoning abilities. We practice our calculation skills in an effort to organize the world of numbers that exists all around us, and we build our reasoning ability so that we are better prepared to solve the variety of problems that we may confront. 

Though these skills are vital, there is a third and often overlooked element to mathematical fluency: the ability to use critical analysis to evaluate a method or argument. It is more difficult to teach and learn this, in no small part because as a skill it is less explicit by nature.

There are two ways that we approach this year’s school-wide theme of critical analysis in math classes at Saint David’s. In the Sixth Grade, boys learn about proportion and scale by crafting a model of a street collection mailbox in miniature. 

The challenge lies in the requirements that the model mailbox be made from a single continuous sheet of paper and that it stand upright in the palm of the boy’s hand. Early in the process, boys find it important to sketch and share their ideas about how to do this. As they learn from each other’s approaches, they build their sense of the relationship between two-dimensional and three-dimensional space. 

There is another layer to this type of learning, though. The perspective gained from the process of sharing designs often causes a student to recognize a flaw in his own design. He may revise his design independently, or he may incorporate an idea from his classmate in response. This is an example of critical analysis in action among students. Students are evaluating each other and letting this lead them to generate their own ideas. 

At times, the teacher may intervene with an individual student to point out a potential stumbling point. More infrequently, the teacher may even suggest an alternative design element to a student who is struggling to generate an idea. Ideally, the teacher does not become involved as an evaluator until late in the game; the goal is to provide our students the opportunity to learn from and critique each other’s ideas.

This process also opens the door to consider the social implications of critical analysis. Because there is more than one “answer” to the design question, disagreements inevitably arise about the best or most efficient way to design a model mailbox. A student who believes in the efficacy of his own design must realize that another student’s design, though different from his, is also valuable. This serves as a pathway for learning about respectful disagreement, and the idea that there is often more than one correct method and more than one correct answer. 

The balance we hope that the boy achieves is conviction in his own ideas but a willingness to change his mind after reflecting upon a reasonable argument.

The ability to evaluate a mathematical argument is a focus  of the Eighth Grade program as well. As they progress through their intensive study of algebra in the Seventh and Eighth Grades, boys solve problems with incrementally increasing levels of abstraction. 

In order to ensure accuracy, they find that it is essential to break apart a problem and analyze each step. A single step within a single algebra problem must be analyzed in several ways. For example, students must check that a step follows logically from the previous step, that it abides by the relevant mathematical principles, that it is accurately notated, and that it leads logically to next step. 

By the time they reach the Eighth Grade, this critical analysis of an algebra idea plays a larger role. At times boys are cued to identify specious reasoning in a multi-step math solution. At other times this cue is taken away and a flaw is hidden deep within an apparently airtight mathematical argument. The ability to identify hidden flaws can then be applied to a student’s own work and improve his own accuracy.

I always tell my eighth graders not to let anyone “push them around” mathematically, including their math teacher! It is so valuable for each student to discover for himself if he believes that a particular mathematical argument holds water. He should consider the argument carefully, consult his prior knowledge of the subject, and consult (but not automatically adopt) the point of view of a trusted source before forming an opinion. 

The alternative to this process would be to believe an argument just because it sounds plausible on the surface. It is vital that our students be better evaluators of merit than that.  

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

NE Patriot Tom Brady at Saint David’s

Last night, Saint David’s was honored to have one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time, four time Superbowl champion and three-time MVP winner Tom Brady, as the guest speaker for our Alumni Parents Council Lecture Series. Tom, who is the father of one of our Saint David's boys, addressed a standing-room-only audience in Hyman Hall comprised of our eighth graders, alumni, alumni parents and faculty. Friendly, introspective, witty, and wise, he directed his talk to the delighted eighth graders in the front of the room, and focused on the topic of leadership. “You are the young men and leaders of Saint David’s,” he noted. Tom debunked the perception that leaders are born not made, and credited his leadership abilities to “standing up to and facing fears” and to “cultivating a mental strength,” which he cited as “more important than being physically strong.” He also stressed the importance of working hard, honoring teamwork, believing in oneself and being a good lis

Surf's Up for Horizons at Saint David's

Little can top catching a wave to beat the heat on an exceptionally hot summer's day. Yesterday, as the temperatures soared into the nineties, the Horizons at Saint David's Eighth Grade class traveled to Rockaway Beach with their teachers for surf lessons with New York's premiere surf school, Locals Surf School. The boys have been taking swimming lessons through our program since their first summer with us in 2012.  At that time, they were were rising first graders, and our inaugural cohort of Horizons students. Yesterday, they were ready to go, and, as these pictures show, they had a blast while learning a new skill. This is the eighth year of Horizons at Saint David's, a six-week multi-faceted academic and cultural summer experience whose mission is to prevent summer slide in elementary school boys from low-income families. We began the program in conjunction with Saint David's 60th anniversary in 2011, as one way that Saint David's as an ins

"Lord of the Flies" Survival Game

Seventh graders are immersed in an "island survival" adventure related to their study of William Golding's 1954 classic Lord of the Flies . The novel tells the story of a group of school-age boys marooned on an uninhabited island, where they struggle to survive without a government or rules. In this creative, unique activity that spans 10 class sessions, our boys are assigned to belong to one of two "tribes." Using knowledge gained from history classes in the fall, they first determine what type of government system to adopt. During the simulations, they strategize methods to overcome obstacles and acquire resources such as wood, food, shelter, and water. The simulation requires the boys to negotiate, debate, and reflect critically on their decisions as they face challenges to their survival. In journals, they regularly write about their thinking, their decisions and consequences. Writing skills are further developed and honed. In addition to analy